Nazareth Mutual Insurance Company

Nazareth Mutual began when a group of Northampton County farmers interested in insuring their homesteads and barns formed Farmers Mutual Fire Company. The group eventually expanded to other homeowners and small businesses. Nazareth, Pennsylvania is currently the home of the Andretti racing family and Martin Guitar. Nazareth is roughly 70 miles outside of Philadelphia. On March, 23, 1846, a Bethlehem township farmer purchased and was issued the first policy for $3.30. Farmers Mutual, Nazareth Mutual Fire Insurance Company formerly Farmers Union Mutual Insurance Company and Citizens Mutual Fire Insurance Company incorporated in 1880. In 1957, all three merged to form Nazareth Mutual Insurance Company. As a Mutual Company, our Policyholders have voting rights and we do not pay stockholder dividends. Our lower price is very competitive to companies that write both Auto & Home together for discounts, but we provide discounts in other areas that promote responsible property ownership. Our company history is all about offering fair, reliable, responsible service from our knowledgeable and experienced staff. Together as a team we can expect to meet the needs of today’s insured. We rely on our strong fundamental business values when working with our agents by providing exceptional service and products to our mutual customers. Personal Service is our Trademark and a good reason why we have been in business this long.